Home

›

›

How to Pre-Sell Before You Build

How to Pre-Sell Before You Build

Money before the product is the strongest validation there is. Here is how founders pre-sell, what each method proves, and what you owe buyers once you take payment.

An open order book and a few coins on a table in front of an empty shelf

Short answer

Pre-selling before you build means asking customers to pay, put down a deposit or sign a commitment for a product that does not exist yet. It is the strongest early test of an idea because it measures what people do with their money, not what they say. It also creates real obligations: delivery dates, refunds and honest updates.

Key takeaways

  • Pre-selling means asking customers to commit money, or a formal promise of money, before the product exists, which is the strongest evidence of demand you can get early.
  • The four common forms are pre-orders, deposits, letters of intent and paid pilots, and each proves something different.
  • In the United States, taking orders for physical goods by mail, internet or phone brings shipping and refund duties under the FTC’s Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule.
  • A deposit counts as payment under that rule, so the shipping clock starts when you receive it with a complete order.
  • Clear delivery dates and refund terms protect buyers and make your validation signal more reliable.

Of all the validation methods, pre-selling is the one most likely to settle the question. A founder can argue with interview notes for months; it is much harder to argue with ten people who paid. It is also the method founders are most nervous about, because it feels like selling something you do not have and because they are unsure what they owe the people who pay. Both concerns have workable answers.

Why money is the signal that matters

People’s words are cheap and their commitments are not. Rob Fitzpatrick’s The Mom Test describes three currencies a customer can pay you in: time, reputation and money. Money is the clearest, and the book lists letters of intent, pre-orders and deposits as examples of that kind of commitment. A pre-sale turns a vague “I’d use that” into a decision the customer had to make.

A pre-sale also tests your price, your message and your reach at once. Those questions come back later in How to Price Your Product and How to Get Customers for a New Business, and a pre-sale gives you a first answer to all of them.

The four ways to pre-sell

MethodWho it suitsWhat the buyer commitsWhat it provesWatch out for
Pre-orderConsumer products, books, courses, hardwareFull price, paid nowWillingness to pay the real priceDelivery dates and refund duties
DepositHigher-priced products, custom work, waitlistsA part of the priceSerious intent at a stated priceA deposit is still a payment
Letter of intentBusiness buyersA signed statement of intent, usually without paymentA company is willing to put its name to itOften not binding
Paid pilotBusiness software and servicesA fee for a limited, defined trialA company will pay for a specific resultPilots that never become contracts

Pre-orders

A pre-order is a full sale with delayed delivery. It suits products with a clear specification and a delivery date you can estimate with some confidence: a book, a course with a start date, a batch of physical goods.

Crowdfunding is the public version. Pebble, the smartwatch maker, turned to Kickstarter in 2012 after venture firms were reluctant to invest; it set a goal of $100,000 and raised more than $10 million from 68,928 backers, as SiliconANGLE reported. Its follow-up campaign for Pebble Time in 2015 set a $500,000 goal and passed $20 million, becoming the most-funded Kickstarter campaign up to that point. Most pre-sales are far smaller, but the principle is the same: a pre-order can answer the demand question and fund production at once.

Deposits

A deposit asks for part of the price now and the rest on delivery. It lowers the barrier while still asking for money, which suits higher-priced and custom products.

Founders sometimes treat a deposit as something softer than a sale. Legally, at least for physical goods in the US, it may not be. The FTC’s business guide to the mail order rule says an order is properly completed when you receive the correct full or partial payment, in whatever form you accept, together with the information you need to fill it. A deposit with a completed order starts the clock.

Letters of intent

A letter of intent (LOI) is a signed document in which a business says it intends to buy, often with an expected price, volume or timeline. It is common when the buyer cannot pay before a product exists.

An LOI is a reputation commitment more than a financial one. Whether it binds anyone depends on its wording and on the law where it is signed. A guide from the law firm Faegre Drinker on Minnesota law notes that letters of intent are generally treated there as nonbinding “agreements to agree,” but that a letter can become binding if the parties clearly show they intend to be bound, and that calling a document a letter of intent does not by itself make it nonbinding. If you plan to rely on LOIs, have a lawyer look at the wording.

For validation, ask what the signer had to do internally. A letter that went through a budget owner is worth more than one signed in a meeting.

A paid pilot is a short engagement in which a business pays for a limited version of your product, with a clear goal and an end date. It sits at the top of the evidence ladder for business ideas: someone with a budget decided your result was worth money.

A pilot is only as useful as its terms. Before starting one, agree in writing on what success looks like, how long the pilot runs, what it costs, and what happens if it succeeds, ideally including the price of the full contract. A pilot without a conversion path can run for months and still tell you nothing. Selling directly to your first business buyers is covered in more depth in Founder-Led Sales.

What the law expects when you take money early

This section summarizes US federal rules for general information. It is not legal advice, and state laws and other countries’ rules may add obligations.

The FTC Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule

If you sell physical merchandise to customers in the US by mail, internet or phone, the Federal Trade Commission’s Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule (16 CFR Part 435) applies. According to the FTC’s business guide, the main duties are these:

  • Ship on time. If you state a shipping time, you must be able to ship within it. If you state none, you must reasonably expect to ship within 30 days of receiving a properly completed order. If the buyer applies for credit with you to pay and you state no time, the period is 50 days.
  • Have a reasonable basis. Any shipping promise must rest on information a prudent businessperson would trust, such as expected demand, supply and fulfillment capacity. Without records, the rule presumes you had no reasonable basis.
  • Notify buyers of delays. If you cannot ship on time, you must tell the customer before the promised date (or within 30 days if you promised none), give a revised date or explain why you cannot, and offer the option to cancel for a full, prompt refund, with a free way to cancel.
  • Handle long delays carefully. For a delay of 30 days or less, silence can count as consent. For a longer or indefinite delay, the notice must say the order will be canceled automatically if the customer does not agree. A second delay always needs the customer’s express consent.
  • Refund promptly. When an order is canceled, refunds paid by cash, check, money order or third-party credit card are due within seven working days. If you extended the credit yourself, you have one billing cycle. Store credit or vouchers do not count as a refund.

The guide lists civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation. The rule covers merchandise, not services, so a consulting engagement or a service pilot falls outside it. That does not make a service pre-sale a place to cut corners: the same honesty about dates and refunds applies.

“Dry-testing” a product that may never ship

The guide also covers promoting a product before deciding whether to make it, which the FTC calls dry-testing. The rule stays out of the way only under strict conditions: you make no suggestion the product will ship, you disclose that it is only planned and may never ship, and if you have not decided within a reasonable time, you tell buyers, let them cancel and promptly refund any payment. Take money while implying the product is coming, and the full rule applies.

Crowdfunding is not a free pass

In 2015 the FTC settled a case against a crowdfunding creator. According to the agency, Erik Chevalier raised more than $122,000 from 1,246 backers on Kickstarter for a board game, spent most of the money on personal expenses, and neither delivered rewards nor gave refunds after canceling the project 14 months later. The settlement barred him from misrepresenting any future crowdfunding campaign and required him to honor any stated refund policy, along with a suspended judgment of $111,793.71.

Kickstarter’s own rules point the same way. Its help center says funded creators must complete the project, deliver rewards and report delays. Under terms updated in 2014, as Tubefilter reported, a creator who cannot finish must explain how funds were used and either offer remaining money back to backers without rewards or explain how the project will be completed in another form.

Refund honesty

The law sets a floor. Founders who pre-sell well usually go above it.

Write the refund policy before the sales page. Say plainly who can get a refund, until when, and how. If your delivery date is an estimate, say so. “Full refund at any time before delivery, no questions asked” is the simplest version, and it removes most of a buyer’s anxiety.

Send updates before people ask. The FTC requires delay notices for physical goods, and the habit is worth keeping for every pre-sale. Silence costs trust.

Refund fast when you stop. If the pre-sale fails, return the money quickly and explain why. A clean refund leaves the door open to sell to the same people later.

A clear refund policy also gives you a cleaner signal: people paid because they wanted the product, not because the terms were confusing.

How to run a pre-sale

  1. Define the offer. One product, one price, one delivery date or access date, one refund policy.
  2. Choose the right form. Pre-order or deposit for consumers and small buyers; LOI or paid pilot for businesses.
  3. Set your bar in advance. Decide how many sales, from how many people reached, would make you build. Write it down.
  4. Go to people who have the problem. Your existing conversations, communities where buyers already gather, and direct outreach usually beat a cold launch.
  5. Take real payment, and keep records. A “reserve now, pay later” button measures curiosity. Log orders, promised dates and notices from day one.
  6. Decide, then deliver or refund. If you cleared the bar, build what you sold, ideally starting from a small first version as described in How to Build an MVP. If you did not, refund and use what you learned.

When pre-selling is the wrong test

Pre-selling is a poor fit when you cannot estimate a delivery date, when the product depends on technology you have not proven, or when buyers must try it before buying. A concierge test, a single-feature MVP or a narrow paid pilot may then give you money-backed evidence with less risk of broken promises. The validation pillar compares these options side by side.

Frequently asked questions

Is it legal to pre-sell a product that does not exist yet?

Generally yes, as long as you are honest about it and meet your obligations. In the US, physical goods sold by mail, internet or phone fall under the FTC’s mail order rule, which sets shipping, delay notice and refund requirements.

How long do I have to ship a pre-order in the US?

Under the FTC rule you must ship within the time you state, or within 30 days of a properly completed order if you state none (50 days if the buyer applies for credit with you). If you cannot, you must notify the buyer and offer a full refund.

Is a letter of intent legally binding?

Often it is not, but it depends on the wording and the applicable law; a letter can become binding if the parties clearly show they intend to be bound. Have a lawyer review any LOI you plan to rely on.

Should I offer refunds on pre-orders?

Yes. The FTC rule requires them in many situations, and a clear refund policy makes buyers more comfortable paying early.

Adam J. Peters Avatar

Continue exploring this topic

Explore the complete guide

How to Validate a Business Idea